Skip to Main Content Back to Top Let's Talk

Mobile

3212 Midtown Park S, Mobile, AL 36606

251-473-4600

Monday - Friday: 8:00am - 4:30pm

Mobile, Alabama, USA, downtown skyline at dusk

Insurance Brokers in Mobile, AL

 


As the largest commercial insurance agency in Alabama in 2024, Higginbotham has the resources of a national firm paired with the personalized service of a local insurance agency. Our team lives, works and plays in Mobile, and we’re committed to giving back to the community where we do business. It’s why we strive to exceed expectations and deliver exceptional, client-centered service.

Lyon Fry Cadden Insurance was founded in 1905 and grew to become one of the largest locally owned independent agencies in south Alabama. In 2022, the team’s ability to provide clients with best-in-class solutions grew when Lyon Fry Cadden joined forces with Higginbotham.

Burkholder Insurance was established in 1951 to serve the needs of the individuals, families and businesses in Mobile and across the Gulf Coast. In 2022, Burkholder became a Higginbotham partner, gaining access to a national network of resources and support.

In 2025, the Burkholder and Lyon Fry Cadden teams united to do business under the Higginbotham name in Mobile. While our name may be different, our commitment to relationship-focused service remains the same. Whether you need homeowners’ insurance, coverage for your business or health insurance options for your employees, at Higginbotham, we believe that you deserve more than just an insurance broker – you deserve a partner who gets to know you and is invested in your success.

Request a Quote

Meet Our Mobile Team

Higginbotham H logo

Business Insurance in Mobile, AL

In the complex area of business protection, Higginbotham’s team offers a complete range of insurance policies and services. With a deep understanding of regional business needs and access to a wide range of coverage options, our team helps to protect organizations in a variety of sectors.

Whether your company requires a single policy or a comprehensive insurance and risk management program, we work closely with you to help design and adjust your coverage as your needs evolve. Our goal is to be a long-term partner in helping to protect your business – not just a provider of policies.

That’s why our Day Two Services® offer support year-round to make sure you get the most out of your coverage. Our in-house services include risk management, safety and loss control, contract review, claims advocacy and so much more.

Two lawyers are discussing about contract paper, law matters determination, pointing.law and hammer on the table
Two lawyers are discussing about contract paper, law matters determination, pointing.law and hammer on the table
Higginbotham H logo

Surety Bonds in Mobile, AL

Securing the right surety bond can be essential to keep your project or business moving forward. It serves as a financial guarantee that the principal (typically the contractor or company) will fulfill their obligations as outlined in the bond, and has become a requirement for many contractors doing business with government entities.

At Higginbotham in Mobile, our team has experience guiding contractors, businesses and sole proprietors through the bonding process. We support a wide range of surety bond needs, including:

Whether you’re working on a complex construction job or need protection against employee dishonesty, our goal is to simplify the bonding process and provide responsive service at every step.

Personal Insurance in Mobile, Alabama

At Higginbotham, we believe your personal insurance should evolve with you. Our team in Mobile helps individuals and families to find coverage that fits their lifestyle, assets and stage of life – from buying a first home to planning for retirement.

We get to know your needs, and then we build a personal insurance program that aims to reduce coverage gaps and simplify your protection. With access to a wide range of insurance carriers and policy options, we’re here to support you through every chapter of life.

Private Client Insurance

Owning high-value property and assets often comes with complex insurance needs. Higginbotham’s private client insurance services are tailored to help protect high-value homes, luxury vehicles, vacation homes, fine jewelry, classic cars, art collections, yachts and more.

We work with insurance carriers that specialize in high-net-worth coverage to help create personalized solutions that reflect your lifestyle and risk profile. Our dedicated team offers attentive, year-round service to help support your long-term protection and peace of mind.

SniorCoupleOnTennisCourt
Higginbotham H logo

Employee Benefits Brokers in Mobile

Providing employee benefits is more than just offering coverage – it’s about helping your people feel supported. At Higginbotham in Mobile, our local team is here to help you deliver benefits that reflect your workforce’s needs while aligning with your business goals.

With the resources of a national firm and the personal service of a hometown partner, we help employers navigate plan design, compliance and long-term benefits strategies with care and clarity. Our team can also work with your existing insurance providers to help enhance your benefits offering without starting from scratch.

Health Insurance in Mobile, AL

Choosing the right health insurance coverage is a key part of building a benefits package that supports both your team and your company’s bottom line. That’s why Higginbotham’s team in Mobile works with businesses across the state to help them design and manage health plans that balance coverage, cost and flexibility.

Gap Health Insurance for HDHPs

Gap insurance can help offset out-of-pocket costs that come with high-deductible health plans. This supplemental coverage can work alongside your existing health insurance to help employees manage expenses like deductibles and copays.

Higginbotham’s team can work with your current health insurance provider to identify opportunities for gap coverage, allowing your organization to offer employees added financial protection without changing your core benefits.

Self-Funded Captives

Higginbotham can help employers turn their existing health insurance plan or other group policies into a self-funded program without needing to change insurance providers. A self-funded strategy may offer greater control over plan design, claims management and long-term cost-containment – all while keeping the insurer that your employees are already familiar with.

Our team in Mobile can help evaluate whether a self-funded benefit captive aligns with your business goals, and, if it does, we’ll guide you through the transition to a more flexible funding model.

Cropped shot of young Asian woman handling personal banking and finance with laptop at home. Planning budget and calculating expenses. Managing taxes and financial bills. Wealth management. Digital banking habits. Smart banking with technology
Higginbotham H logo

Comprehensive Benefit Services

A strong employee benefits offering requires more than just selecting the right plans – it also demands ongoing service and support to help keep your program effective year-round. That’s why Higginbotham’s Day Two Services® are built to assist both employers and employees long after open enrollment ends.

Our in-house benefit services are designed to help reduce your HR team’s administrative burden, boost employee engagement and support your organization’s long-term benefits strategy.

Professional services of this caliber are typically available only through multiple vendors, but Higginbotham can perform a variety of functions in a seamless, coordinated effort with your own human resource initiatives. Our value-added services include:

Your Insurance Partner in Mobile, AL

At Higginbotham in Mobile, we bring together local insights and broad capabilities to help protect what matters most to our clients – whether that’s a growing business, a personal legacy or the well-being of their team.

With a commitment to people-first service and customized solutions, our team is here to support you at every stage. Connect with us and discover the Higginbotham difference – when your insurance broker is your partner.

Talk to a Member of Our Team

Meet Our Team

Headshot of Paul H. Burkholder III

Paul H. Burkholder III

Managing Director

Paul is a graduate of McGill-Toolen Catholic High School and Auburn University with a bachelor’s degree in accountancy. He went on to become a Certified Public Accountant (CPA “retired”) while working for an international accounting firm prior to joining his family’s insurance agency in 1989. Since then, he’s helped clients of all sizes with their commercial and personal insurance needs. He specializes in coastal property, contractor and garage liability insurance.

Paul is an active member of the community, having served on many community service boards. When he’s not in the office, he enjoys spending time on the water or in the woods. Paul and his wife, Patti, have three children and are members of St. Ignatius Catholic Church.

Email Paul

Headshot of Erling Riis III

Erling Riis III

Managing Director, CPCU, CIC

Erling is known for his community leadership and service to others, a legacy that began as an undergraduate at Sewanee: The University of the South. He entered the insurance profession in 1990 and has earned numerous industry certifications and awards. Clients appreciate his expertise in hard-to-place coverages. Erling has served the industry locally and nationally, including as past president of the Mobile Association of Independent Insurance Agents and a representative to the Big “I” Legislative Conference in Washington, D.C.

When he’s not assisting clients, Erling devotes his time to numerous civic organizations. He has held leadership positions for the Mobile Area Chamber of Commerce, Mobile Arts and Sports Association, Mobile Touchdown Club and the Coastal Conservation Association. He and his wife, Jeri, have two sons.

Email Erling

Headshot of James W. Goodloe III

Bill Goodloe

Managing Director, CIC, AAI

Bill served as Vice President of Lyon Fry Cadden until the firm’s merger with Higginbotham in 2022 and now serves as Managing Director. He is a native of Mobile and an alumni of the University of Alabama, graduating with a bachelor’s degree in business. Bill began his career in sales for a local manufacturing company before finding his way to the insurance industry in 1999. Leveraging an extensive network of carriers to create unique solutions, he specializes in contractors, coastal real estate and professional/management liability insurance.

When he’s not at the office, Bill enjoys spending time outdoors with his wife and their two sons. Bill and his family are members of Spring Hill Baptist Church.

Email Bill

Headshot of McCrary Otts

O. McCrary Otts IV

Managing Director, CIC, CRM

McCrary serves as Managing Director at Higginbotham and holds a Bachelor of Science in Finance from the University of Alabama. As Managing Director, McCrary delivers property and casualty insurance to businesses and individuals throughout Alabama. McCrary has honed his expertise in bond production throughout the Southeast, particularly within the construction industry. His extensive knowledge, steadfast commitment to customer service and strong ties to the community make him a go-to resource.

He and his wife, Elizabeth, have three children and are members of the Covenant Presbyterian Church.

Email McCrary

Headshot of Spence Adams

Spence Adams, IV

Managing Director

Spence began his insurance career in 1993 at his father’s agency, Pickett & Adams Insurance. Since then, he’s been dedicated to providing innovative solutions that are designed to mitigate risk and reduce rates for his clients. He specializes in marine, property, church, casualty and life insurance. In 2002, he became an owner of Pickett & Adams before selling the agency in 2008. He continued his insurance career as a sales executive until he joined Lyon Fry Cadden Insurance in 2014.

Spence is passionate about giving back and regularly shares his time and talents with his community by volunteering on multiple committees.

Email Spence

Headshot of Brad Elliott

Brad Elliott

Employee Benefits Consultant

With over 20 years of business management experience, Brad is known for his outstanding customer service and ability to foster lasting client relationships. He holds a bachelor’s degree from the University of Alabama and an MBA from Millsaps College. Brad began his career in the pharmaceutical industry before entering the surgical device space, where he spent 17 years in progressively senior roles. Following a meaningful five-year sabbatical to focus on his family as a full-time dad, he joined Higginbotham in 2024.

Outside of the office, Brad enjoys spending time with his wife, Kimberly, and their four children. He is an active member of Saint Paul’s Episcopal Church and an avid outdoorsman.

Email Brad

Headshot of Randy Fry

Roland G. “Randy” Fry, Jr.

Producer, CIC

Randy joined our team after graduating from the University of South Alabama in 1983 with a bachelor’s degree in finance. He was selected as Young Agent of the Year by the Alabama Independent Insurance Agents in 1991. Since then, he has garnered the Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation and numerous long-term clients.

Randy previously served as president of the Mobile Association of Independent Insurance Agents and chair of the Alabama Independent Insurance Agents Young Agents Committee. He has served the community as president of the Daphne City Council and chairman of the Daphne Utilities Board.

He and his wife, Elizabeth, are members of Springhill Avenue Temple, where Randy is a past president. A Baldwin County resident, Randy has been active in Daphne Band Boosters and as a YMCA youth coach. He enjoys golf and family time at the beach.

Email Randy

Headshot of George Oswalt

George G. Oswalt

Producer, CISR, ARM

George Oswalt graduated from Sewanee: The University of the South with a bachelor’s degree in English. He began his insurance career in Nashville, handling policy placement and customer service processes for hundreds of companies of all sizes and industries. In 2016, George moved home to Mobile and joined the team. His areas of focus include commercial property owners, high-value homeowners and growing businesses. He holds the Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) and the Associate in Risk Management (ARM) designations.

George is involved in the Mobile Touchdown Club, the Senior Bowl Committee, the Propeller Club of Mobile and Government Street Presbyterian Church. In his spare time, George enjoys spending time with his family in Gulf Shores or Point Clear.

Email George

Headshot of Joanna L. Brinson

Jody Brinson

Producer, CIC, CPRM

Jody began her insurance career in 2007 after graduating from the University of Georgia with a degree in business management. She began her career working in the marketing department at an insurance brokerage in Birmingham before returning home to Mobile and joining Lyon Fry Cadden Insurance (now Higginbotham) in 2009. With over 15 years of experience in the insurance industry, she specializes in helping high-value homeowners, real estate investors and growing businesses find the right coverage for their unique needs. She holds the Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) and Certified Personal Risk Manager (CPRM) designations.

Jody and her husband, Charles, have three children and are active members of St. Paul’s Episcopal Church.

Email Jody

Headshot of Emory Jones

Emory Jackson Jones III

Producer

Emory brings over 15 years of sales experience, primarily in the construction industry. Whether on site or in the office, his professional priority has always been helping clients with their needs so they can succeed. Emory is a graduate of Bayside Academy and attended the University of South Alabama. He is a former member of the Homebuilders Association and the Associated General Contractors of America.

Outside of work, Emory has a strong passion for the outdoors and loves to spend time in nature with friends and family. Emory and his wife, Brittany, have two children and attend 3 Circles Church in Fairhope.

Email Emory

Ed Cadden

Vice President

For Ed, insurance runs in the family. His father made a successful career in Mobile and, since 1977, Ed has forged the same path of distinction. A University of Alabama graduate, Ed brings unmatched experience to clients, particularly in the area of contractors’ insurance and surety bonds. Additionally, he is certified through the National Association of Surety Bond Producers.

When he’s not in the office, Ed devotes his time to the Mobile West Rotary Club, where he has served as a board member for several years. He’s also actively involved with Christ Anglican Church. Married with two sons, Ed enjoys fishing and deer hunting.

Email Ed

Headshot of Taylor B. Peterson

Taylor Peterson

Producer

Taylor is a commercial insurance producer with nearly 15 years of experience in the insurance industry. He is a graduate of McGill-Toolen Catholic High School and the University of Alabama. In his free time, Taylor is an avid fisherman and enjoys spending time with family and friends on the water.

He and his wife, Christi, have two children who are very involved in sports at their school, and they are members of Ashland Place United Methodist Church.

Email Taylor

Mobile

3212 Midtown Park S